The Perfect Pair: What to Serve With Gold Star's Holiday Coffees
There's a moment every holiday season when the house finally goes quiet. The wrapping paper is gathered up, the dishes are soaking, and someone asks the best question of the night: "Who wants coffee?"
At Gold Star Coffee, we think that cup deserves just as much thought as the meal before it. A great flavored coffee can stand on its own. Pair it with the right dessert or breakfast, though, and something special happens. The coffee brings out flavors in the food, the food brings out flavors in the coffee, and the whole thing tastes bigger than either one alone.
That's why we put together this guide to our five holiday flavors: Santa's Kiss, Eggnog, Jack Frost, Candy Cane and After 8. For each one, you'll find our top pairing pick, a few backups, and what to steer clear of. Whether you're hosting a family brunch, building a dessert table, or just treating yourself on a snowy afternoon, you'll know exactly what to put on the plate.
One quick note before we dive in. Every Gold Star flavored coffee starts with our premium Arabica beans, roasted to a medium city roast. We add our flavoring extracts right after roasting, while the beans are still warm, so the flavor goes deep instead of sitting on the surface. That gives you a cup that tastes like real coffee first, with the flavor layered on top. That balance is what makes these coffees work so well with food.
The two holiday flavor families
Our holiday lineup falls neatly into two groups, and knowing which is which makes pairing easy.
- The mint family: Jack Frost, Candy Cane and After 8. Cool, bright and refreshing, these love chocolate and simple vanilla sweets.
- The warm spice family: Santa's Kiss and Eggnog. Cozy, nutty and comforting, these shine next to buttery baked goods, nuts and a touch of citrus.
Keep those two families in mind and you'll rarely go wrong. Now let's get specific.
Santa's Kiss: nutty cinnamon with a touch of orange peel
Santa's Kiss is the coffee version of walking into a kitchen where something is baking. You get warm cinnamon and toasted nuts up front, then a bright little lift of orange peel at the finish.
Our top pick: panettone. This tall, airy holiday bread is studded with candied orange and raisins, and it matches Santa's Kiss almost note for note. The citrus in the bread picks up the orange in the cup, and the soft, buttery crumb rounds out the cinnamon. Toast a slice, add a little butter, and you have one of the best holiday breakfasts around.

Also great with:
- Cranberry-orange scones
- Dark chocolate with orange, a classic holiday combination
- Cinnamon buns or sticky buns
- Glazed ham at a holiday brunch, where the orange and spice act like a built-in glaze
Skip: heavy mint desserts. Mint and orange tend to fight each other in the same bite.
Eggnog: nutmeg and creamy custard
Eggnog captures everything people love about the holiday drink, without the heaviness. Think warm nutmeg, a hint of vanilla and a smooth, custardy finish.
Our top pick: classic butter shortbread cookies. Shortbread is simple on purpose: butter, sugar and flour. That simplicity is exactly why it works. It doesn't compete with the coffee. Instead, its rich, buttery crunch gives the nutmeg and custard notes room to come forward. Dip a cookie in the cup and you'll see what we mean.
Also great with:
- Pecan pie, where the toasted nuts and caramel echo the custard
- Cinnamon French toast or a stack of waffles for holiday brunch
- Bread pudding or rice pudding
- Gingerbread, for a spicier take
Skip: sharp, tart fruit desserts like lemon bars. The acidity cuts right through Eggnog's creamy character.
Jack Frost: chocolate candy cane and Irish cream
Jack Frost is the most indulgent coffee in our holiday lineup. It layers chocolate, cool candy cane and smooth Irish cream into one cup that tastes like a winter dessert.
Our top pick: fudgy chocolate brownies. A dense, chewy brownie has enough chocolate to stand up to the mint, and the Irish cream in the coffee softens every bite. It's the same reason mint chocolate chip ice cream works so well: the chocolate grounds the mint, and the cream ties them together. Warm the brownie for ten seconds before serving and it gets even better.

Also great with:
- Chocolate cheesecake
- Irish cream truffles or chocolate-dipped pretzels
- Hot chocolate cookies topped with a marshmallow
- Simply topped with whipped cream and crushed candy cane, as a dessert in its own right
Skip: fruity pies and citrus. They clash with both the mint and the cream.
Candy Cane: pure, cool peppermint
Candy Cane is the simplest flavor in the group, and that's its strength. It's clean, bright peppermint over smooth coffee: the taste of the holidays in one sip.
Our top pick: peppermint bark. It might seem obvious to pair peppermint with peppermint, but it works for a good reason. The layers of dark and white chocolate in the bark give the mint something rich to cut through, so every sip of coffee feels like it's cleaning up the last bite and setting up the next one.
Also great with:
- Plain frosted sugar cookies, which let the peppermint take center stage
- Chocolate lava cake
- Chocolate chip cookies
- Vanilla bean ice cream, with a shot of the coffee poured over the top
Skip: fruit and citrus desserts. Peppermint and fruit almost always clash, so save the apple pie for one of the spice flavors.
After 8: chocolate mint
After 8 is named for the moment it was made for: after dinner. It's smooth chocolate with a cool mint finish, like the thin chocolate mints passed around the table at the end of a holiday meal.
Our top pick: a chocolate yule log (bûche de Noël). This rolled chocolate sponge cake, frosted to look like a log, is the centerpiece of many holiday dessert tables. Its light sponge and rich chocolate frosting pair perfectly with After 8, and the mint in the cup keeps a big dessert from feeling too heavy after a big dinner.
Also great with:
- Vanilla shortbread or butter cookies
- Black forest cake
- Chocolate-covered almonds
- An affogato: a scoop of vanilla ice cream with hot After 8 poured over it
Skip: spiced desserts like pumpkin pie. The cinnamon and clove muddy the clean chocolate-mint profile.

Hosting a holiday coffee bar
Want to try several pairings at once? Set up a simple coffee bar for your next gathering.
- Brew two coffees, one from each family. We like Jack Frost and Santa's Kiss together. Guests get one cool, chocolatey option and one warm, spiced option.
- Put each dessert beside its coffee. Brownies next to Jack Frost, panettone next to Santa's Kiss. Guests will pair them without needing instructions.
- Add a toppings station. Whipped cream, crushed candy cane, cinnamon sticks and grated nutmeg let everyone dress up their cup.
- Don't forget decaf. Every holiday flavor is also available as Swiss Water decaf, so late-night guests can join in.
Create your own holiday blend
Can't choose just one? With our Make Your Own Flavor option, you can combine up to three flavors into a custom bag. A few of our favorite holiday combinations:
- Hot Cocoa by the Fire: Jack Frost + Toasted Marshmallow
- Candy Cane Latte: Candy Cane + French Vanilla
- Night Before Christmas: Santa's Kiss + Eggnog
- Mint Cookie Crumble: After 8 + Cookies & Crème
Make this season taste better
The best holiday memories are usually made around a table. With the right coffee and the right treat side by side, that table gets a little sweeter. Pick up your favorite holiday flavors at Gold Star Coffee while they're in season. They also make an easy, thoughtful gift for the coffee lover on your list, and our 6 lb flavored combo pack lets you try several at once.
Happy holidays, and happy pairing.
Frequently asked questions
What dessert goes best with peppermint coffee?
Peppermint bark is our top pick for Candy Cane coffee. Its dark and white chocolate layers give the mint something rich to cut through. Chocolate lava cake and frosted sugar cookies also work well.
What should I serve with eggnog flavored coffee?
Classic butter shortbread. Its simple, buttery crunch lets the nutmeg and custard notes come forward. Pecan pie and gingerbread are great alternatives.
What foods should I avoid with mint flavored coffee?
Skip fruit and citrus desserts. Peppermint and fruit almost always clash, so save apple pie or lemon bars for a warm spice flavor like Santa's Kiss or Eggnog.
Are Gold Star's holiday flavors available in decaf?
Yes. Every holiday flavor comes in both regular and Swiss Water decaf, so late-night guests can enjoy a cup too.
Can I mix two holiday flavors in one bag?
Yes. With our Make Your Own Flavor option you can combine up to three flavors in one bag, such as Santa's Kiss with Eggnog or Candy Cane with French Vanilla.